Courage to be less helpful

http://www.peterpappas.com/2011/07/teachers-have-courage-to-be-less-helpful.html

One of the upsides (or downsides depending on your perspective) to twitter is that the people I follow post really good articles and I know they are good articles, pre filtered for me.

“Unfortunately, most of our students get a steady diet of force-fed information and test taking strategies. We’re giving a generation of kids practice for predictable, routine procedures – and that happens across the “bell curve” from AP test prep to meeting minimal proficiency on NCLB-mandated tests.”

I was just posting on twitter this morning questioning the value of giving tests where we are afraid to give the test on a Monday because they will have forgotten it over the weekend. Or the validity of a test where the students learn it for the test and forget it.  Did the test itself actually accomplish something? Can I really record in my gradebook that I taught and they mastered that standard if they can not remember it for even 2 days?

Peter Pappas beat me to the punch though and wrote an article that also calls this into question. I enjoyed the article, see the link above to read it yourself.

 

 

Lisa Highfill

lhighfill Lisa Highfill

@RobrtMiller – love the article! RT just read tinyurl.com/4387u8t Surely will elicit initial dismay of my incoming students. #gtawa

Leave a Comment

© 2026 All Rights Reserved.

💥 FREE OTIS WORKSHOP

Join Alice Keeler, Thursday April 15th or register to gain access to the recording.
Create a free OTIS account.

Join Alice Keeler for this session for teaching with AI

Unlock a smarter way to manage your curriculum by turning your own teaching materials into a personalized AI assistant with NotebookLM. This session explores how to transform static documents into interactive study guides and audio overviews that are tailored strictly to your specific content. You will discover how this versatile note-taking tool can streamline your prep time and help you organize complex resources with ease. Join us to see how NotebookLM can act as a powerful, free partner in your K-12 classroom.

Exit this pop up by pressing escape or clicking anywhere off the pop up.