Grading with a Rubric

On occasion I have observed some rubrics being utilized to create numerical grades that do not correspond to the rubric scale.

For example on a 3 point rubric scale
3 = excellent
2 = average
1 = poor

A score of 2 being average but a 2/3 = 66% is not an average score.

Since I like spreadsheets I like to do my rubric grading I created a video to show how to create a formula to grade rubrics.
Here is a link to a template for writing a formula. View the Rubric tab and double click on cells to view the sample formulas.

Here are my steps

  • Have students fill out a Google Form to submit their First Name, Last Name, Email Address and possibly link to their assignment if it is digital.
  • This information will go to a spreadsheet (note in the new Google Forms you have to specify that you want the information to go to a spreadsheet)
  • In the column next to the students names make columns for
    • Overall Grade
    • Each element of the rubric
    • Note to the student
    • Repeat the columns for each element but to not name them the same.
  • Put in default scores for each category and copy and paste down the spreadsheet.
  • In the columns that will translate the rubric score you will want to use a nested if statement.
    I used in cell I2: =if(E2=3,100,if(E2=2,70,if(E2=1,50,0)))

    • if the score is 3 give the person 100%, if the score is 2 give the person 70% and if the score is a 1 give the person a 50%, otherwise give them a zero.
  • Copy and paste the formula to the right for each of the rubric columns.
  • Copy and paste those formulas down for all students in the list.
  • Your grade will now reference the columns that convert the rubric score to the percentages you determined.
  • For the grade itself, determine how you would weight each rubric score and multiply that by each column percentage.
    I used in cell D2: =I2*.25+J2*.5+K2*.25

    • 25% of the score is the first rubric item, 50% of the score is the second rubric item, and 25% of the score is the third rubric item.
  •  Insert the valmerge script if you want to email back feedback to the students.
    • Insert->Script
    • Search valmerge
    • You may want to click on the help link to find the sample valmerge template.
    • Install the script
    • Create a new tab
    • Copy and paste the valmerge information
    • Fill out the script information.
  • I have a column for send.  I wanted the formula to say “y” if I had graded the assignment and be blank if I had not.
    =if(H2=””,””,”y”)
    • If the note field is blank do nothing, otherwise put a y.
    • Notice the quotations, all text needs to be in quotations

Leave a Comment

© 2026 All Rights Reserved.

Get effective EdTech strategies from Alice Keeler to build a more student centered classroom. Includes unique resources and templates.

Recent Teacher Tech Blog Posts

💥 FREE OTIS WORKSHOP

Join Alice Keeler, Thursday April 28th or register to gain access to the recording.
Create a free OTIS account.

Join Alice Keeler for this session for teaching with AI

Imagine having a team of teaching assistants who already know your syllabus and exactly how you like to give feedback. Join Google Certified Innovator Alice Keeler to learn how to use Google Gems to build a powerful collection of custom AI tools. We will explore how to engineer specific instructions so you can create a Grading Assistant or a Classroom Policy Manager that works for you. You will also learn how to leverage Gems shared by other educators to instantly expand your toolkit. This session is about super-powering your teaching by automating the routine tasks so you can focus on the students.

Exit this pop up by pressing escape or clicking anywhere off the pop up.